Last refreshed Oct 29, 2026 · 19 days ago8-factor methodology · v3.2 · sources linked on every rowIndependent research. No paid rankings.Why trust Pledge ›

How Pledge scores Bitcoin treasury products.

This page explains the seven-factor scoring model used to rank BTC treasury products like preferred stock and common equity vehicles. It covers what each factor measures, how it is scored, where the data comes from, and what the methodology cannot capture.
Composite scores range from 0 to 10. 7 weighted factors sum to 100%. Data checked Aug 23, 2026. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Scoring factors
7
Each factor is weighted and scored 0–10 before blending into a composite.
Total weight
100%
Factor weights sum to 100%. No hidden adjustments.
Sources per product
4+
SEC filings, press releases, market data, and third-party cross-checks.
Limitations
Documented
NAV estimates, data lag, and product-specific caveats are listed explicitly.

Seven weighted factors determine each treasury product's composite score.

Every factor is scored 0–10 and then multiplied by its weight. The weighted scores sum to the overall composite score (0–10). No hidden adjustments.
30% weight30%

NAV Premium / Discount

How far the market price sits from the estimated bitcoin net-asset value per share, in either direction. Trading near NAV scores highest; a large discount (the market doubts the NAV will be realized) or a large premium (speculative demand beyond bitcoin exposure alone) both score lower as the deviation from fair value grows.

Evidence checked

Market price from exchange quotes (Yahoo Finance, StockAnalysis)

BTC-per-share NAV computed from total BTC holdings ÷ shares outstanding × reference BTC price

Premium/discount = (market price − NAV) / NAV

Scoring bands

−5% to +5%: 9–10 (near NAV — market price tracks fair value closely)

−20% to −5% or +5% to +20%: 6–8 (moderate discount or premium)

beyond −20% to −30% or +20% to +30%: 1–4 (extreme discount or premium — large deviation from fair value in either direction)

15% weight≥ 15%

BTC per Share

The amount of direct bitcoin exposure each share represents. Higher BTC per share means the instrument tracks bitcoin more closely, all else equal.

Evidence checked

Total BTC held by the issuer (from SEC filings, press releases, BitcoinTreasuries.net)

Shares outstanding (from SEC filings, market data)

BTC per share = total BTC ÷ shares outstanding

Scoring bands

≥ 0.01 BTC/share: 8–10 (high exposure)

0.001–0.01 BTC/share: 5–7.5 (moderate exposure)

< 0.001 BTC/share: 2–4.5 (diluted exposure)

15% weight≥ 15%

Dilution Rate

Whether the share count is growing, stable, or shrinking. Increasing dilution erodes per-share BTC exposure over time. ATM programs, convertible notes, and secondary offerings all contribute.

Evidence checked

Shares outstanding trend (current vs. prior period)

Active ATM programs and capacity disclosed in SEC filings

Convertible note and warrant overhang from prospectuses

Management guidance on issuance policy

Scoring bands

Decreasing or stable: 7–10 (shareholder-friendly)

Increasing at moderate pace: 4–6 (some dilution pressure)

Increasing rapidly with large ATM/convertible capacity: 1–3 (significant dilution risk)

15% weight≥ 15%

Governance

Quality of public disclosure, audit standards, and regulatory compliance. Better governance means investors can verify claims independently.

Evidence checked

SEC reporting status (full reporter vs. OTC vs. unlisted)

Disclosure frequency (quarterly 10-Q, annual 10-K, 8-K current reports)

Audit firm name and reputation (Big Four vs. national vs. none)

Bitcoin proof-of-reserves or third-party verification

Scoring bands

SEC reporting, Big Four audit, frequent disclosure: 8–10

SEC reporting, national audit firm: 6–7.5

SEC reporting, no audit firm disclosed: 4–5.5

OTC or limited disclosure: 1–3.5

10% weight≤ 10%

Liquidity

How easily shares can be bought and sold without moving the market. Daily volume and exchange listing tier matter for investors who may need to exit.

Evidence checked

Daily trading volume (from market data sources)

Exchange listing tier (Nasdaq Global Select, NYSE, Nasdaq Capital Market, OTC)

Bid-ask spread when available

Scoring bands

Daily volume > $100M, major exchange: 8–10

Daily volume $10M–$100M, major exchange: 6–7.5

Daily volume $1M–$10M: 4–5.5

Daily volume < $1M or OTC: 1–3.5

10% weight≤ 10%

Fee Structure

Direct costs charged to holders. Most treasury products do not charge management fees, but some have embedded costs, performance fees, or structural drag from operating expenses.

Evidence checked

Management fee (basis points)

Performance fee (percentage)

Other disclosed fees or cost structures

Operating expense ratio for public companies

Scoring bands

No management or performance fee: 8–10

Low management fee (<50 bps), no performance fee: 6–7.5

Moderate fee (50–100 bps): 4–5.5

High fee (>100 bps) or performance fee: 1–3.5

5% weight≤ 10%

Track Record

How long the product has been publicly traded. A longer track record provides more data points for evaluating NAV stability, dividend consistency, and management execution.

Evidence checked

Inception date or first trading date

Dividend payment history (for preferred stock)

BTC accumulation track record over time

Scoring bands

≥ 3 years: 8–10

1–3 years: 5–7

< 1 year: 1–4.5

The overall score is a simple weighted sum.

No machine learning, no secret sauce. Each factor score (0–10) is multiplied by its weight, and the results are added together.
Overall = Σ (factor_score × factor_weight)

NAV Premium / Discount: score × 30%

BTC per Share: score × 15%

Dilution Rate: score × 15%

Governance: score × 15%

Liquidity: score × 10%

Fee Structure: score × 10%

Track Record: score × 5%

Example (STRC): NAV Premium 9.9×30% + BTC/Share 7.5×15% + Dilution 2.5×15% + Governance 8.5×15% + Liquidity 9.0×10% + Fees 7.0×10% + Track Record 1.5×5% = 7.4

Every data point is traced back to a named source.

Primary sources are SEC filings and official company releases. Market data and third-party aggregators are used as cross-checks, not primary sources.
Data source

SEC EDGAR filings

10-K annual reports, 10-Q quarterly reports, 8-K current reports, and prospectuses. These are the primary source for BTC holdings, share count, dilution, and governance disclosures.

Data source

Company press releases and investor relations pages

Official announcements of BTC purchases, dividend declarations, ATM program updates, and strategic changes. Cross-referenced with SEC filings when possible.

Data source

BitcoinTreasuries.net

Third-party aggregator of public company BTC holdings. Used as a cross-check against company-reported figures, not as a primary source.

Data source

Market data providers

Yahoo Finance and StockAnalysis.com for market prices, trading volume, and shares outstanding snapshots. Market data is treated as "partial" verification because prices move intraday.

Scores change when the underlying data changes or when the methodology is corrected.

These are the conditions that trigger a score review.
Review trigger

BTC holdings change materially

A large purchase or sale of bitcoin by the issuer changes the NAV per share and BTC-per-share metrics.

Review trigger

Share count changes significantly

ATM program executions, convertible note conversions, or secondary offerings change dilution and per-share metrics.

Review trigger

Market price moves sharply relative to NAV

A large change in premium/discount changes the NAV premium factor score even if underlying BTC holdings are unchanged.

Review trigger

Governance or disclosure quality changes

A new audit engagement, loss of auditor, change in SEC reporting status, or change in disclosure frequency can move the governance score.

Review trigger

The methodology is corrected

If a scoring rule or weighting is adjusted, the change is noted on this page with an explanation of why.

What this methodology does not capture.

A scoring model is only as good as its inputs. These are the known gaps — they are documented here rather than averaged away.

NAV per share is an estimate using a reference BTC price and does not include all corporate assets, liabilities, debt, taxes, warrants, or operating costs.

BTC holdings data may lag real-time by days or weeks depending on SEC filing and press release timing.

Market data (price, volume) reflects a point-in-time snapshot and may not represent current conditions.

Scores for products with less than one year of trading history are inherently less reliable.

The methodology does not capture issuer credit risk, legal risk, or regulatory risk beyond what is publicly disclosed.

Common equity products (XXI, NAKA) carry additional operating-company risks not reflected in the BTC-focused score.

Preferred stock products (STRC, SATA) depend on issuer solvency and board discretion for dividend payments.

Use these pages alongside the methodology.

The methodology connects to the comparison product, the main lender methodology, and the disclosure policy.

Not investment advice. Pledge provides comparison data for educational purposes only. All comparison data is a dated snapshot checked Aug 23, 2026. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Affiliate disclosure. No paid rankings or link-level referral fees. No revenue channel is live today: paid introductions on $1M+ loans are planned, not active — see /trust. If we ever add link-level referral fees, every monetized link will carry ↗ AFFILIATE.

Data accuracy. NAV estimates use a reference BTC price and may not reflect all corporate assets, liabilities, debt, taxes, or operating costs. Market data is point-in-time and may be delayed.

Securities risk. Treasury products are securities subject to market risk, credit risk, dilution risk, and regulatory risk. Scores do not capture all relevant risks. Read the full limitations section above.

Also Compare