Methodology v3.2 · last full review October 16, 20268 factors · 100% total weight · published openlyIndependent research. No paid rankings.Why trust Pledge ›
METHODOLOGY · v3.2

8 factors. Weighted. Public.

Every Pledge safety score is the weighted sum of a fixed, published factor set — eight factors for lenders, stablecoins, custody, and ETFs alike. This page documents the eight-factor model in full: what each factor measures, what a perfect 10.0 (Strong) looks like, and which evidence sources feed each score.

8
Factors

Each scored 0–10

100%
Total weight

Adds up to 100%

v3.2
Current version

Published October 16, 2026

0
Score overrides

Scores are factor-driven. Highest score in category is the top computed score.

Recurring
Score refresh

Reviewed on a recurring cadence; each row carries its own dated snapshot.

THE 8 FACTORS

How a Pledge score gets built.

Lenders, custodians, dollar products, and ETFs are each scored on eight factors. Weights are fixed and published. Editors don't override individual scores to elevate or demote a product.

Each vertical's factor set is purpose-built — ETFs, custody, and stablecoins weight the variables that actually matter for that structure — but the weighting principle (fixed, published, no editor overrides) stays identical.

01 · rehypothecationWEIGHT 20%
Rehypothecation Policy
10.0 (Strong) STANDARD

Collateral cannot be re-lent, re-pledged, sold, transferred, or otherwise used by the lender or funding partners, and that restriction is explicit in borrower-facing terms.

EVIDENCE1 primary3 fallbackper-product evidence linked on profile pages
02 · custodyWEIGHT 15%
Custody Model
10.0 (Strong) STANDARD

Borrower collateral uses a control model where the lender cannot unilaterally move BTC outside documented liquidation or recovery procedures.

EVIDENCE2 primary3 fallbackper-product evidence linked on profile pages
03 · regulatoryWEIGHT 15%
Regulatory Compliance
10.0 (Strong) STANDARD

The product is offered through a clearly licensed or regulated structure, with visible jurisdiction rules, KYC requirements, and no buried access constraints.

EVIDENCE4 primary2 fallbackper-product evidence linked on profile pages
04 · reservesWEIGHT 12%
Reserves & Transparency
10.0 (Strong) STANDARD

Collateral or solvency evidence is current, independently reviewed, easy to find, and specific enough for borrowers to understand what is actually protected.

EVIDENCE3 primary3 fallbackper-product evidence linked on profile pages
05 · track_recordWEIGHT 10%
Track Record
10.0 (Strong) STANDARD

The lender has a long operating history through multiple Bitcoin drawdowns, meaningful funded volume, and no unresolved borrower-protection red flags.

EVIDENCE3 primary3 fallbackper-product evidence linked on profile pages
06 · liquidationWEIGHT 10%
Liquidation Practices
10.0 (Strong) STANDARD

Margin-call, cure, partial-liquidation, and final-liquidation rules are conservative, specific, borrower-visible, and not dependent on vague discretionary language.

EVIDENCE4 primary2 fallbackper-product evidence linked on profile pages
07 · loss_protectionWEIGHT 8%
Loss Protection
10.0 (Strong) STANDARD

The product adds meaningful borrower downside protection beyond basic margin-call mechanics without hiding material costs or eligibility restrictions.

EVIDENCE0 primary5 fallbackper-product evidence linked on profile pages
08 · transparencyWEIGHT 10%
Transparency & Governance
10.0 (Strong) STANDARD

Borrowers can verify terms, ownership, source evidence, governance, public profiles, and correction paths without relying on sales copy or a private quote flow.

EVIDENCE5 primary3 fallbackper-product evidence linked on profile pages
WHAT A 10.0 (Strong) ACTUALLY LOOKS LIKE

A 10.0 (Strong) Bitcoin loan would be nearly boring.

The borrower keeps meaningful control of collateral, collateral cannot be reused, reserves or collateral handling are independently verifiable, legal status is clear, liquidation rules are conservative and explicit, and the lender has survived multiple market cycles with clean public evidence.

Most real products should not reach 10.0 (Strong) because every borrowing path adds a tradeoff: custodial exposure, smart-contract risk, jurisdiction limits, quote-dependent pricing, liquidation mechanics, or thinner public proof. That does not make a 7 or 8 weak; it means the product is strong relative to a deliberately strict ideal.

WEIGHT ALLOCATION · ALL FACTORS SUM TO 100%
20%
15%
15%
12%
10%
10%
8%
10%
Rehypothecation Policy20%
Custody Model15%
Regulatory Compliance15%
Reserves & Transparency12%
Track Record10%
Liquidation Practices10%
Loss Protection8%
Transparency & Governance10%
CATEGORY ADAPTATIONS

Same spine. Different factors per product type.

Lenders, stablecoins, and custody providers are scored on eight factors; ETFs on their own eight-factor set built for a regulated trust structure (expense ratio, liquidity, tracking error, price/NAV tracking, AUM, issuer credibility, fee transparency, custodian quality). Click any product type below for its exact factor list and weights. Because each category weighs different factors, read a score against its peers in the same vertical — a Digital Credit 7.7 and an ETF 8.4 aren't a one-to-one safety comparison.

Bitcoin loans

Rehypothecation policy, custody model, regulatory standing, reserves, liquidation practices.

Read methodology →
Bitcoin ETFs

Custodian quality, issuer credibility, liquidity, tracking error, expense ratio.

Read methodology →
Custody providers

Key control model, insurance backing, recovery model, proof of segregation.

Read methodology →
Stablecoins & dollar products

Seniority, asset coverage, dividend terms, funding, covenants, and market liquidity.

Read methodology →
Wallets

Open source review, hardware audit, seed-recovery model, threat model.

Read methodology →
Bitcoin mining

Hashrate share, geographic diversification, energy mix, financial disclosure.

Read methodology →
BTC-treasury equities

BTC per share, treasury policy, equity dilution risk, financial reporting.

Read methodology →
Corporate treasuries

Public BTC holdings, custody disclosures, treasury policy documents.

Read methodology →
How Pledge works

Methodology determines rank — full stop.

No paid rankings or link-level referral fees. No revenue channel is live today: paid introductions on $1M+ loans are planned, not active — see /trust. The methodology output IS the rank.

About → How Pledge works ↗
0
Editor overrides

No editor adjusts a score after the methodology computes it. Period.

8
Public factors

Weights, criteria, and evidence sources all documented above.

v3.2
Versioned

Methodology changes are versioned and dated. Old versions stay archived.

Public
Score audit

Every score links to the underlying evidence on the entity's profile page.