Comparison · methodology v3.2Aave ↔ Unchained · side-by-side under the same 8-factor rubricIndependent research. No paid rankings.Why trust Pledge ›
★ Independent comparison · lender-vs-lender

Aave vs Unchained.

Aave (DeFi · non-custodial) compared against Unchained (CeFi · multisig). Same 8-factor methodology, same evidence sources, side-by-side numbers.

A · lender
Aave
DeFi · non-custodial
Pledge Safety Score
8.3/10
APR
4.39–5.19%
B · lender
Unchained
CeFi · multisig
Pledge Safety Score
9.0/10
APR
14.18%
FACTOR-BY-FACTOR

The 8 factors, side by side.

FactorAaveUnchainedΔ
Rehypothecation Policy
Weight 20%
10.0/10
10.0/10
tied
Custody Model
Weight 15%
9.0/10
9.0/10
tied
Regulatory Compliance
Weight 15%
4.0/10
9.0/10
Unchained +5.0
Reserves / Proof
Weight 12%
9.0/10
8.0/10
Aave +1.0
Track Record
Weight 10%
9.0/10
9.0/10
tied
Liquidation Practices
Weight 10%
10.0/10
10.0/10
tied
Loss Protection
Weight 8%
5.0/10
7.0/10
Unchained +2.0
Transparency
Weight 10%
10.0/10
9.0/10
Aave +1.0
Overall Pledge score
8.3/10
9.0/10
Unchained +0.7
Editorial · who to send to which

“Aave is the cheapest dollars in the Bitcoin lending market — variable rate, on-chain, you keep the keys. Unchained is the safest — multisig custody, regulated, fixed rate, but ~10× the APR. Pick by which failure mode you fear more: smart-contract risk (avoid Aave) or institutional custodian risk (avoid Unchained).”

Read full review
Aave →
Read full review
Unchained →